Same Story, Different Medium

Close-up photo of a film clapperboard lying on a reflective surface. The clapper arm features vibrant color stripes in green, yellow, blue, red, white, and gray, while the board shows labeled fields for “Scene” and “Take.”

It isn’t often I can say a renowned figure’s unfortunate passing has made me think of a movie, but with the passing of Pope Francis, the Vatican will need to move through the process of selecting a new head of the Catholic Church. What should I do if I want to find out more about this highly secretive, age-old process? Watch the movie Conclave of course, or, even better, read the novel.

I’m a firm believer that if a film was based on a book, you ought to read the book first, just to know what you’re really getting into. Conclave will be the nth in a long list of book-to-movie adaptations on my list, and it hopefully won’t be the last.

Experiencing the changes a story goes through when adapted for the big screen can be extremely interesting, engaging, or downright awful and upsetting. Books have been turned into movies and shows for decades. Some stories, like Sherlock Holmes and A Christmas Carol, have been turned into several television shows and movies, spanning a little more than 100 years. Even ancient stories, like The Odyssey attributed to Homer, have experienced several film adaptations. These days, popular books are still being moved to the big screen, and below are a few of the newer ones that caught my eye, starting with the most relevant, Conclave.

Conclave

If you ever wanted to know more about the Vatican, seemingly the most important hub of the Roman Catholic Church and one of the smallest recognized countries, put down that history book and look no further than Robert Harris’ Conclave. Those other books may give you an accurate record of events, but they won’t deliver the platinum level mystery of this story. When the pope dies unexpectedly, Cardinal Lawrence has the responsibility of coordinating the most stressful and solemn political campaigning of all time—the Conclave, a voting process culminating in the appointment of a new pope. Being an agent of holiness isn’t a barrier to ambition and conspiracy, however, and Lawrence finds himself becoming a holy detective on a mission to uncover secrets weaved into the very foundations of the Catholic Church.

The Wild Robot

Based on the first book in a series by Peter Brown, The Wild Robot follows a helper robot mistakenly washed up on the shores of an uninhabited island after their carrier vessel sinks. Uninhabited by people that is, but filled to the brim with a wonderful assortment of wild animals. What’s a helper robot to do with nobody to help? Learn the language of the animals and find somebody to help, opposable thumbs or not! Roz was ready to sign up for any task her furry acquaintances could give her, except for the daunting responsibility of motherhood. With a helpless little gosling and a time-limit of migration before the coming winter, Roz learns what it means to actually live.

Wicked

Wicked is technically based on a Broadway play, which was based on a book by Gregory Maguire, which was based on a film from the 1930’s, which was also based on an even older series of books. So at least somewhere down the line, the 2024 film is based on a book. This magical musical follows two witches attending college in the fantastical land of Oz—Elphaba and Galinda. This pair of young women couldn’t be more different: one likes fashion, the other likes books; one comes from an affluent family, the other has had green skin since birth. Watch (or read about) their time at Shiz university, learning magic, making friends, and sneaking out after dark. As you follow these students in their youthful-shenanigans, don’t forget the threat of the future looming above them. How does Elphaba, strangely average freshman, become the Wicked Witch of the West?

Mickey 17 (2025) [Mickey 7]

Mickey 17 was adapted from the novel Mickey 7, which isn’t a confusing name change at all, and definitely didn’t make it harder for me to find it in the catalog... With the creative direction of Bong Joon Ho, director of Parasite, and the storytelling of author Edward Ashton, Mickey 17 (or 7) follows Mickey Barnes, an “expendable,” the guy you send out to the surface of a planet to see if it’s habitable enough for a colony. With the convenience of biological copy-clones, he gets to be virtually immortal, at the expense of his sense of humanity. When one copy, 7 or 17 (depending on the medium), doesn’t actually die on his most recent excursion, he meets 8 (18), and now there are one too many Mickeys on the colony mission. Two Mickeys isn’t the only secret being kept from the higher-ups on this space endeavor however, with a trail of missing and un-uploaded memories fostering distrust in the back of 7’s (or 17’s) mind.

The Nickel Boys

From Pulitzer-Prize winning author Colson Whitehead comes The Nickel Boys, a story about two boys trying to survive the horrors of a juvenile reform school. Although the film has not yet been released on DVD, be sure to read the book, as well as Whitehead’s other critically-acclaimed novels, so you’ll be ready when it is!

It Ends with Us

With a collection of some of the most misleading trailers ever conceived, Colleen Hoover’s It Ends With Us is a deceptively thrilling story. With a scattering of flower petals on the book cover, and a matching meet-cute in a flower store, Lily Bloom’s story resembles a heart-soothing romance. However, not all is moonlight and roses. When a former lover resurfaces, she is forced to reevaluate where she stands, and make the best choice for her future—with or without her abusive husband or the blast from her past. Read the book, and then see how closely the movie mirrors the story!

If these all sound as interesting to you as they do to me, you may be excited to learn that all but one of them have both film and book versions at the library! Having a copy of Wicked would be nice, but what if the colossal differences between the film and the four separate source materials continue to haunt you? No worries, you can always return a copy taken out at the library and leave those unsettling details on the shelves.

-Asha, Ewing Branch

Comments